Jake the Peg wrote:2003
cooke assists 8 Hull FC tries 115 = 7%
2004
cooke assists 21 Hull FC tries 151 = 14%
2005
cooke assists 29 Hull FC tries 131 = 22%
2006
cooke assists 24 Hull FC tries 124 = 19%
2003 to 2006
cooke assists 82 Hull FC tries 521 = 16%
Hope that clears it up
horne has been well and truly injured and ill for the last 2 years, whereas cooke has been found out as an ever present in the dobbins side. Which one will be counting his GB caps in retirement?
Or, if you add tries in:
2003 2004 2005 2006
TotalFC Tries 115 151 131 124
521Cooke assists 8 21 29 24
82Cooke tries 2 5 6 2
15Cooke assists + tries 10 26 35 26
97% 9% 17% 27% 21%
19% Horne assists 4 16 13 12
45Horne tries 10 11 5 15
41Horne assists + tries 14 27 18 27
86% 12% 18% 14% 22%
17%So, no material difference between Horne and Cooke's "contributions" And as you have already said, Swain had a fair number of assists, plus you have Jason Smith, Lupton, Brough, Washy, even McMenemy over that time period.
And, of course, the stability of the halfback combination had no bearing on FC's most successful SL period. Cooke and Horne played together in 94% of games in that time.
2003 2004 2005 2006 Total
Cooke appearances 28 27 25 27 107
Horne appearances 28 27 22 28 105
Total 56 54 47 55 212
Possible appearances 56 58 56 56 226
100% 93% 84% 98%
94%