Joined: Jan 28 2006 Posts: 18736 Location: Baix Empordà, Catalunya
Robbie Rotten wrote::lol: Saviola? It seems like you're the one with the problem, pal. Quite clearly hasn't been up to it at the best clubs as shown in his spells at Barca and Madrid. I'm actually a fan of his, but if you deem him good enough for Liverpool or good enough for England, when he's been nowhere near good enough for either big Spanish side, then you clearly have problems judging players. In real life of course, not FM.
Robbie, are you comparing Liverpool to Madrid and Barça?
RLFans.com Soccer Prediction League Champion 2011/2012
Joined: Mar 07 2007 Posts: 7121 Location: Warrington
Catalancs wrote:Robbie, are you comparing Liverpool to Madrid and Barça?
Ha ha ha.
It depends by what you mean with comparison. Despite our woeful form at the moment, I still believe we're one of the best sides in the world, at least our starting XI is. IMO, the top 4 from England and the top 2 from Spain are the best 6 sides in the world. Barca are better than us, but I'm still to be impressed by Madrid.
Wonder what your going to say if chelsea win the league when your yanks took all that money for Ronaldo meaning you had to buy a forward on a free transfer.
Nobody knows without insider info, United no longer have to declare any transfer fees to shareholders / the stock exchange and the like, so without seeing the books you couldn't be sure. That's what's laughable about the whole exercise.
If Chelsea win the league then good on them. They would've deserved it. I couldn't give a sh*t about net spend. Just because we got £80m or whatever it was for Ronaldo has absolutely no relation to the value for money or quality of the players brought in this year.
RedTez wrote:Nobody knows without insider info, United no longer have to declare any transfer fees to shareholders / the stock exchange and the like, so without seeing the books you couldn't be sure. That's what's laughable about the whole exercise.
If Chelsea win the league then good on them. They would've deserved it. I couldn't give a sh*t about net spend. Just because we got £80m or whatever it was for Ronaldo has absolutely no relation to the value for money or quality of the players brought in this year.
So your fine with Fergie not being even more money for the team from the deal and the owners pocketing the cash?
Wire_85 wrote:So your fine with Fergie not being even more money for the team from the deal and the owners pocketing the cash?
I would've loved to sign Villa and Silva, but we haven't. Rather than whinge about it, we have to get on with what we've got. No excuses, no moaning, we've spent enough in the past (like you) to compete for the league. That's what we need to be doing.
Fresh Prince of Chesh-air wrote:Arguing about which club has spent more?
You all sound like married couples arguing who has maxed out the joint credit card.
I'm attempting not to argue about that fact (not very well!). My point is regards to the ridculous stat of "net spend". It's a load of rubbish. United have a reported net spend of what? -£60m this season? I still expect us to compete for 4 trophies.
Joined: Jan 28 2006 Posts: 18736 Location: Baix Empordà, Catalunya
RedTez wrote:I would've loved to sign Villa and Silva, but we haven't. Rather than whinge about it, we have to get on with what we've got. No excuses, no moaning, we've spent enough in the past (like you) to compete for the league. That's what we need to be doing.
RLFans.com Soccer Prediction League Champion 2011/2012
Joined: Jun 24 2002 Posts: 17949 Location: Newton-le-Willows - East Side of the Fence
Wire_85 wrote:I have explained why we aint won the title, am not going through it again.
and the team is no better than it was when he started
Erm it is alot better 1 to 11 we just lack the back up players.
City fans and many other clubs fans would give there right bolllock to see there team do what Liverpool have done in his 5 years here.
What is United's "net spend" over the same period? I bet that will give you a damning statistic on how well Benitez is doing
Hate it when people compare us its a joke big difference being they had/have an established squad of class players then they just add £15/20mil+ players
City would have indeed been delighted to have done what Liverpool had done but City fans and Liverpool fans have had a very different level of expectancy over the years and still do.
Remember, it's not that long ago that United had finished way off the pace, in third, behind Chelsea and Arsenal and so-called experts predicted their demise, the fans were in uproar about Glazer and the place was not a happy camp. They've won three league titles since and what has that vital "net spend" been since? You may not like the comparison but it just goes to show.
Let's face it, apart from Gerrard and Torres, how many of your players would any top club clamber to have in their side? Not only does the squad outside the 1-11 not look good enough for the top, the team is nowhere near of the standard required. Have you ever known a top side be so heavily reliant on the fitness of just two players? There's only one bloke who's fault that is.
MANCHESTER CITY - PREMIER LEAGUE CHAMPIONS 2011-12 BORUSSIA DORTMUND - BUNDESLIGA CHAMPIONS 2011-12 CELTIC - SPL CHAMPIONS 2011-12 ALEMANNIA AACHEN - HOPELESS 2011-12 ST. HELENS RLFC - ER.. 3 OUT OF 5 AIN'T BAD!
Joined: Mar 07 2007 Posts: 7121 Location: Warrington
Yeah, because Gerrard & Torres save goals, control games and do everything.
They're our best players, they're arguably the two best in the league, we're obviously going to be reliant upon them more than any of our other players; however, I do believe some of our other players get little credit for what they do. Benayoun is class, he's always creating stuff yet he's barely spoken of; why? Mascherano is one of the finest players around at doing what he does, the amount of games he keeps us in with his work rate and tenacity really does pass most people by.
IMO, Reina, Agger, Skrtel, Aurelio, Johnson, Mascherano, Benayoun, Gerrard and Torres are all easily good enough for the top sides. It's the rest of the squad we fall short on. We have some players who are boarderline top quality, like Kuyt, Carragher (now he's starting to get on) and Insua's still very raw.
I still believe we'll finish top 4, quite comfortably actually, but we're just gonna have to ride out this next month or so.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 37 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum