Get rid!

Smith out and Thorman in, yeah?

* Optimist peeks through a gap in the door *

Why change one scapegoat for another? Smiths defence is better than thormans, we dont need another turnstile.

Smith is a getting a very bum deal from our supporters at the moment, when he performes the team usually does in the middle of the season myler got all the headlines it was smith imo that gave him the opportunities to shine.

He is a organiser, who gets us ticking over so myler or rachford can work their magic,

Hopefully he'll get the confidence and his form will return, the mistakes will dry up he'll stop getting abuse and he can get back to making our team tick

* Optimist shuts the door, locks it again and sits under the table *

No No No!!

Thorman is bloody awful.

Granted he has the odd (Very odd) great game, just has too many sub-par ones to be worth a punt.

Replacing Smith with Thorman would be like replacing a wooden leg with a giant strap-on...

One or two people seem to be taking my comment a little too seriously

smith out resign mike neill the classy red headed aussie half back sheer classssssssssssss

I thought Smith was one of the criminal masterminds that were responsible for the untimely death of Ernest Bishop. Some of us (including Emily Bishop) will NEVER forgive him even if he excels at stand-off, loose forward and wins The Man of Steel.

Dreadful. He's probably playing like a turd because he's guilt ridden.

Re the Butcher - Which Thorman are we talking about ? the one who plays for Gateshead Thunder ?
Re willowsshed/ optimist - as I'm another 'Smith's fan do I also seek Sanctuary in the room under the table ?