The question is, would we have still collapsed in the second half had we gone in 12-0 up at HT?

probably!

We'll never know, the doom and gloomers will though.

Maybe we could try something different as we are never going to get in the 8! Stop Agar doing the half time team talk and see how we perform in the 2nd half!

we might have hung on for a draw

Here's one for you

If Raynor's try had stood at Caravan Shed would we have held on for victory . My feeling is no, as in the next set of 6, an injured Fisher brushes off 4 sh*t tacklers for the try.
I also am still in disbelief that we lost there when we had the hailstorm from hell and they still had 2 drop goals in last 10 minutes to win.

Giants have the best defence in SL and we didn't get one point - luck ?

Also they have the best defence since Sharp left and they haven't really signed anyone. Defence is a barometer of how team spirit and fitness is.

At the moment I'd take that TBH.

I was at the game on friday and came away very despondent but i have to say after watching the highlights i think we were very hard done by.