I very nearly slipped into a coma whilst going back through the MOM threads but for those still interested.........

Saints

Berro
Thorman
Thackray

Wakey

Broughton
Motu
Yeamo

Salford

Yeamo
Raynor
Tickle

Wire

Berro
Yeamo
Broughton

Leeds

Berro
Moa
Whiting

Cas

Moa
Whiting
Manu

Season So Far

Dowes = 13
Berrigan = 13
Calderwood = 12
Manu = 10
Yeaman = 10
R.Horne = 9
Tickle = 9
Thackray = 6
Moa = 5
Thorman = 4
Broughton = 4
G. Horne = 4
Whiting = 3
Lee = 3
Houghton = 3
Maloney = 3
Radford = 3
Cusack = 3
Motu = 2
Raynor = 2
Burnett = 2
Byrne = 1
King = 1
Washbrook = 1

Still plenty to play for in terms of the "best of a bad bunch" awards

Thanks for spending your time on that Robbo, much appreciated

when were the other 3 games???

each to their own and all that, but i can't see how people have decided Dowes has been our best player this season at all, he's been very average.

Horne is just in their on past reputation also IMHO, I can't see how he's made an impact on 9 games. He's been poor all season in my eyes.

the rest is around about right though IMO

Dowes was in good form and instrumental in our early season run. I guess that is where he picked up votes.

TBF though, dowes probably got 5 of his points from the first 5 games, also a few after that, the bloke was doing 70 minute spells!

Why would he have needed to make an impact on nine games? He could have obtained those points in three.

Early games that we won I would guess.

Yep. He played a big role in the games against Celtic, Huddersfield and Bradford.

Looks like Berro v Calderwood then.