OOC at the end of this season and deffo worth a new deal imo. Was very good for Quins the other night scoring a try as well as saving a couple at the other end. He has a tremendous work ethic and can clearly play at this level.

Thoughts??

Always thought he had a lot of potential, and should've got a chance here especially considering Galea and Newton have looked in need of a rest in recent weeks.

The only way these lads are going to become super league players, is by playing super league rugby. Morgan took a chance with Welham and it paid off, I'd like to see him do that more often.

He looked the part for Quins - a couple of slight and understandable misunderstandings with his new team mates apart. If we are going to keep him, we have to be willing to play him, though - others have have been preferred when injuries might have given him an opportunity.

And one sub appearance isn't really enough to earn a new deal for a player of his age. If it was a straight choice between him and, say, Netherton, I'd have to go with the latter and promote another player from the academy/U21.

If Quins offer Esders a deal, it might be better for his career than staying with us - especially with Scott Taylor also being a 2nd row.

Not seen enough of him to really base a firm opinion on if he is worth a new contract. I wasnt really impressed with the small role he played in the first team earlier on this season, so I would like to see how his loan spell goes before deciding on his future.

Well worth a new deal IMO.

He's well worth a new deal if on potential alone...

I saw him last season for York and he was great (yes i know its only Co-Op 1)...i think he plays in the Gilmour mould, in that hes comfortable in the second row or centres...

shouldnt you be showing more then just potential by now though? hes about 26 isnt he?

Do you actually follow the game???

Of course.... but i dont know every players age Gord!


***but ive now checked and hes only 23***

worth a chance, depending on the amount he wants as he will only be a squad player - but i think Quins will offer him more money!

very red robin wrote:Of course.... but i dont know every players age Gord! Do a bit of research prior to posting and you wouldn't look so daft

very red robin wrote:Of course.... but i dont know every players age Gord! Do a bit of research prior to posting and you wouldn't look so daft