Joined: Jan 04 2006 Posts: 7069 Location: Green Bay
Dawg wrote:Fitzgerald Moss Boldin T.O Johnson
I agree he is a brilliant recieverm but to place him in the top 3 is a bit of a reach.
I'd go:
Larry Fitzgerald
Andre Johnson
Greg Jennings
Calvin Johnson
Randy Moss
Roddy White
I agree though, it's all relative and subjective. Fitz and Andre Johnson are the clear top two IMO. Then it is a bit more debatable. I rate Jennings as three but i can understand why people say lower.
Joined: Mar 20 2009 Posts: 484 Location: in me wigan shirt and cap
ST_CONROY wrote:I'd go:
Larry Fitzgerald Andre Johnson Greg Jennings Calvin Johnson Randy Moss Roddy White
I agree though, it's all relative and subjective. Fitz and Andre Johnson are the clear top two IMO. Then it is a bit more debatable. I rate Jennings as three but i can understand why people say lower.
Joined: Mar 20 2009 Posts: 484 Location: in me wigan shirt and cap
ST_CONROY wrote:More yards Younger Bigger average yards per catch/game Bigger deep threat target More first down catches
He gets less respect than if he played for a big market team.
I meant atrribute wise, I disagree that he is a bigger deep threat target as well, Moss can outmuscle/outjump any DB in the league, but as you say it can all be about opinion.
Joined: Sep 03 2005 Posts: 7651 Location: The Midlands
IMO Moss is slightly overrated, he's always needed good players around him in order to produce, look at his time in Oakland for example, whereas Andre & Calvin Johnson have both played for teams who don't make the playoffs and are the best players for both teams on the Offensive side of the ball.
Schrödinger's Cat wrote:IMO Moss is slightly overrated, he's always needed good players around him in order to produce, look at his time in Oakland for example, whereas Andre & Calvin Johnson have both played for teams who don't make the playoffs and are the best players for both teams on the Offensive side of the ball.
Definitely - you'd put your money on him to go up there and get the ball when it is thrown to him but there are far better route runners in the NFL who make Moss look one-dimensional.
Joined: Mar 15 2009 Posts: 16166 Location: Foxborough, Massachusetts
Adamjk wrote:Definitely - you'd put your money on him to go up there and get the ball when it is thrown to him but there are far better route runners in the NFL who make Moss look one-dimensional.
I dont think hes ever pretended to be anything other than a deep threat guy or someone who runs good routes, im still surprised when he catches a ball anything less than 10 yards im always expecting it to be Wes Welker
Schrödinger's Cat wrote:IMO Moss is slightly overrated, he's always needed good players around him in order to produce, look at his time in Oakland for example, whereas Andre & Calvin Johnson have both played for teams who don't make the playoffs and are the best players for both teams on the Offensive side of the ball.
What about when Moss was in Minnesota ? He had Daunte Culpepper and Cris Carter.
Science flies people to the moon. Religion flies people into buildings.
Last edited by Dead Man Walking on Sat May 30, 2009 2:25 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: Jan 04 2006 Posts: 7069 Location: Green Bay
Dawg wrote:I meant atrribute wise, I disagree that he is a bigger deep threat target as well, Moss can outmuscle/outjump any DB in the league, but as you say it can all be about opinion.
Jennings seems like a good personality and a very good teamate from the interviews i've seen. Very good hands and is a very good route runner. I'd say he's pretty good everywhere.
He has more catches of 20 yards and 40 yards or more than Moss. Jennings isn't somebody who will go up and get it, he can do it but it isn't his absolute strength. He is extremely good on the cut and i'd say can beat most corners at a break and outrun most.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum