PAUL M wrote:No it doesn't, it maybe shows that Fozzard was not doing so well? Either way if you asked any fans in SL who Rovers Key players are I very much doubt Lovegrove would get a mention, it would be Dobson, Cooke, Vella, Galea and Briscoe.
Gavin Miller - Legend wrote:It guess it depends how you interperate KEY mate.
How about irreplaceble players, for instance if you were to lose Cooke and Dobson how would your team fare then ? By that not as a dig purely as an example, no point using an FC one because we are papp with or without. Simular to Saints Losing both Long and Pryce or Leeds losing both Sinfield and Burrows.
PAUL M wrote:No it doesn't, it maybe shows that Fozzard was not doing so well? Either way if you asked any fans in SL who Rovers Key players are I very much doubt Lovegrove would get a mention, it would be Dobson, Cooke, Vella, Galea and Briscoe.
Dealt with their injuries quite well this year, if you ask me.
pmarrow wrote:How about irreplaceble players, for instance if you were to lose Cooke and Dobson how would your team fare then ? By that not as a dig purely as an example, no point using an FC one because we are papp with or without. Simular to Saints Losing both Long and Pryce or Leeds losing both Sinfield and Burrows.
We lost Cooke for a few games early on and managed ok'ish with I'anson, guess if Dobbo was ever out injured Murrell would revert to S.H.
Granted class half backs are needed for a team to be at their best but some teams manage to cover injuries to key players better than others. IMO a fully fit Vella is a key player for HKR and TBH i am surprised we have been as effective without him as we have. Saying that Lovegrove, until his injury, was Rovers form prop.
Alphabetti Spaghetti Go! wrote:whatever, check the number of posts from me on the FC board, compare it to your number on here, then come back to me.
Argh but we are not questioning that.
Alphabetti Spaghetti Go! wrote:For a rookie prop, I will happily compare Lovegrove's metres/game stats with anyone in the whole comp. Does that make you feel better?
EL CAMO wrote:Basically get rid of 2 players that left Hull (Briscoe and Carvell) and include a Hull player.
Take those specs off.
No simply becasue Smith offers far more in attack than Briscoe and Carvell is a liabilty will the amount of penalties and injuries he has
I also said someone like R Horne if you could read properely: a player who can cover any position in the back line - ideally i would put leyon pryce on the bench and start with a different stand off
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 120 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
