not again wrote:watch the incident again, he fell awkwardly because he was out before he hit the ground. definately a swinging arm. first point of contact was gilmour forearm on JW jaw.

not again wrote:i cant believe what people are saying. watch the tackle again, and keep an eye on gilmour's left forearm why he has made connection with JW jaw when he does'nt have the ball is dirty. JW was out before he hit the ground and gilmour didnt go for the ball he just swung at JW head. I cant believe people can argue with what is right in front of you. slow it down its BAD!!

Blobbynator wrote:I've just seen it on Sky Sports News and it was just a standard tackle from Gilmour.

Best wishes to Joe in his recovery.

not again wrote:and that matters because???

Gaslight wrote:Standard? if that was a standard tackle for Gilmour he would never play, a swinging arm hitting a players chin is a penalty, a late high tackle is a sending off, so he deserves 3 games at the very least.

not again wrote:firstly glad to hear joe is ok never good to hear of these things. I just watched the incident and its a swinging forearm to the jaw, from gilmour and i'll bet he is in alot of trouble. it was dirty as JW did'nt even have the ball.