Joined: Jan 29 2007 Posts: 5695 Location: Wigan, unfortunately.
The Joker® wrote:Peacock and Fielden are different types of animal to James Graham, Graham is a more modern day ball handling prop and Peacock and Fielden are more let's get stuck in and bash the other forwards around or run into brick walls type players hence more suited to the NRL...
I wouldn't say Fielden's really bashed anyone around since he joined Wigan. He's gone steadily downhill.
Joined: Oct 26 2006 Posts: 6212 Location: Republic of Uganda
~ No1 Saints Fan ~ wrote:I wouldn't say Fielden's really bashed anyone around since he joined Wigan. He's gone steadily downhill.
When he was at Bradford he was the best Prop Forward in Super League and any team would have wanted Stuart Fielden playing for them, you could also say he was one of the best Prop Forwards in the World at the time aswell...
The Joker® wrote:When he was at Bradford he was the best Prop Forward in Super League and any team would have wanted Stuart Fielden playing for them, you could also say he was one of the best Prop Forwards in the World at the time aswell...
Similar to James Graham right now ?
Yet one could do really well in the NRL and one could go okay ?
Hmmmm, the difference ? One plays for St Helens.
getdownmonkeyman wrote:You need to move on from here. SS has replaced you, he gets this debating/conversing lark far, far better.
Joined: Oct 26 2006 Posts: 6212 Location: Republic of Uganda
Stirlingshire Saint wrote:Similar to James Graham right now ?
Yet one could do really well in the NRL and one could go okay ?
Hmmmm, the difference ? One plays for St Helens.
No Stuart Fielden and James Graham are completely different types of Prop Forward as i posted earlier, and no i wouldn't say similar to what James Graham is now///
Why does one playing for St Helens make the difference?, I have already mentioned i consider Matt Gidley the best Centre in Super League and i rate Jon Wilkin highly also Fielden was playing for Bradford Bulls you know the main local rivals of Leeds Rhinos...
The Joker® wrote:No Stuart Fielden and James Graham are completely different types of Prop Forward as i posted earlier, and no i wouldn't say similar to what James Graham is now///
I agree, one is exceptional at his job making more metres on a consistent basis than anybody else. One is as fragile as a feather and generally does nothing except embarrass himself everytime he takes the field.
Even Fielden at his pomp, I'd like to see the stats comparison to see how they compare. My guess would be that Graham would still be ahead but without the nonsense fist cocking everytime hit hard.
getdownmonkeyman wrote:You need to move on from here. SS has replaced you, he gets this debating/conversing lark far, far better.
Graham makes alot more meters and carries from less games.
Fielden makes a massive amount of tackle busts and clean breaks, but his error count/missed tackles is quite big as well.
Graham makes alot more meters and carries from less games.
Fielden makes a massive amount of tackle busts and clean breaks, but his error count/missed tackles is quite big as well.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
