So where do we think they are all now , a quater of the season gone, a few trips and bumps showing now, what do we think
Heres my opinion ( and i have not included the injured boys)

Calderwood 6 out of 10 so far no service at all
Yeaman 4 out of 10 not kicked on from last year at all
R Horne 9 out of 10
Thorman 7 out of 10
Dowes 8 out of 10 i just want him to break a tackle or two....
Berrigan 7 out of 10
Cussack 8 out of 10
Radford 9 out of 10
Tickle 9 out of 10
Manu 8 out of 10
G Horne 7 out of 10
Thackery 6 out of 10
King 5 out of 10
Houghton 8 out of 10 good start for the lad , looks good
Briscoe 8 out of 10
Lee 7 out of 10
Hall 7 out of 10
Moa 5 out of 10

Agree wall-y except maybe Houghton would give 6.

Calderwood 6
Yeaman 6
R Horne 9
Thorman 8
Dowes 9
Berrigan 7
Cusack 9
Radford 8
Tickle 8
Manu 8
G Horne 8
Thackray 7
King 5
Houghton 7
Briscoe 8
Lee 7
Hall 8
Moa 6

Would agree with that but Dowesy has broken a few tackles this season.

some people just have it it in for yeaman full stop . 4 is a bit harsh . tink dowes has been great and has broke a few tackles , hall isnt 8 he's done ok but still very inconsistent .no way has houghton bin better than berro you tell a difference when he's off.

Are you the guy who wrote of our entire squad in a previous thread ststing they were all either "workman like" or "not good enough" !?!?!

and now your dishing out 8/9's out of 10

Your more fickle then my mother-in-law.

Or, i could have mistaken you for another poster. If that's the case - apologies.

nope not this one