That is why Parramatta were such a good side - Smith was rubbish - overhyped - he simply did not deliver on the field.

Finch is so good even Bird got the SOO gig before him - get a life at least watch a few games - you might educate yourself

ill bet you didnt even know finch played origin.

and off the top of my head i think tim smith won a Dally M rookie of the year award as well.

when his form was good he was doing some amazing things at half back.

nathan hindmarsh after round 2 was ranked 2nd in most tackles made in the nrl.

100 tackles in 2 games = average of 50.

http://www.canberratimes.com.au/news/na ... 72381.aspx probably why Mason resorted to the drink!!

http://www.canberratimes.com.au/news/na ... 72381.aspx probably why Mason resorted to the drink!!

Just to make it simple for you.

Nathan Hindmarsh is not a stand off.

You have claimed earlier in this very thread that stand offs in the NRL make 30 tackles a game. All ER is asking you to do is to provide some evidence of this.

Stop avoiding the question by making statements about your laughter and answer it. Then people may start to take you a little serious.

the guy was making fun of nathan hindmarshs tackling you silly boy

if you are trying to derail something it helps to read the thread first.

nathan hindmarsh isnt a what?

Yes that is on another tangent.

However, ER is attempting to clarify your point that stand offs in the NRL make 30 tackles a game. You said it, now can you back that up ?

If you can't then just accept that you were incorrect and exaggerating and stop avoiding the question. It is so obvious its embarrassing.

dally,

Why do you think McGuire would not adapt as well as Ellis has, given that McGuire was a better defender (in terms of tackles % rate) than Ellis?

ffs do you have any life other than the NRL!