Joined: Jan 23 2005 Posts: 1824 Location: Yorkshire
Dobson isn't as bad as B&W fans make out, most of his missed tackles are when he's kick chasing, as with Kris Welham. Still plenty of work needed for both.
A unknown superstar wrote:He's just come back from virtually a full season out FFS!
A unknown superstar wrote:Name me out of the HB's in SL who are better than Horne. Without the statistics.
Brough, Cooke and Monaghan off the top of my head imo.
I'm not saying Horne is a bad defender, as he gets targeted in defence as most half backs do, but to suggest he's the best in the league is going too far.
Dobson isn't as bad as B&W fans make out, most of his missed tackles are when he's kick chasing, as with Kris Welham. Still plenty of work needed for both.
A unknown superstar wrote:He's just come back from virtually a full season out FFS!
A unknown superstar wrote:Name me out of the HB's in SL who are better than Horne. Without the statistics.
Brough, Cooke and Monaghan off the top of my head imo.
I'm not saying Horne is a bad defender, as he gets targeted in defence as most half backs do, but to suggest he's the best in the league is going too far.
Joined: Feb 09 2008 Posts: 9342 Location: King George Dock
Matty wrote:Dobson isn't as bad as B&W fans make out, most of his missed tackles are when he's kick chasing, as with Kris Welham. Still plenty of work needed for both.
Brough, Cooke and Monaghan off the top of my head imo.
I'm not saying Horne is a bad defender, as he gets targeted in defence as most half backs do, but to suggest he's the best in the league is going too far.
Monaghan? Your having a laugh arn't you?
Brough is really good, Cooke is pretty good also.
Matty wrote:Dobson isn't as bad as B&W fans make out, most of his missed tackles are when he's kick chasing, as with Kris Welham. Still plenty of work needed for both.
Brough, Cooke and Monaghan off the top of my head imo.
I'm not saying Horne is a bad defender, as he gets targeted in defence as most half backs do, but to suggest he's the best in the league is going too far.
Monaghan? Your having a laugh arn't you?
Brough is really good, Cooke is pretty good also.
"You don't have to be great to start, but to be great you have to start".
Joined: Jan 02 2003 Posts: 43413 Location: rlfans flying wing man
Matty wrote:Dobson isn't as bad as B&W fans make out, most of his missed tackles are when he's kick chasing, as with Kris Welham. Still plenty of work needed for both.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 22 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
marvellous comeback 
