He was good but you are talking greats and the sign of greatness is medals.

Mike Mc i will disagree with you on Goulding, in my opinion he was a catalyst for where we are now, he is arrogance and selfishness instilled a winning mentality.

I dont really agree with that, a great player can play in a poor team.

Cough (Ricky Bibey) Cough
Indeed, that's why I'm dissapointed that Newlove isn't in Ski's list.

Players like Bibey Mason dont stay around long enough to get a host of medals.

The second one with the '66 cup winners badge is my favourite.

A few alterations will take place over the next couple of days, but it is REALLY coming together.

Both are superb , but I prefer the second one as well , fantastic work

I like the idea of having a retro badge, but I think the flag with the modern badge looks better as it is a bit less busy.

Sorry to throw a spanner in the works, especially as I provided a list for Ski to analyse, but Dick Huddart anyone?

I think Wardy is a must if we are going for Cooper. The man was a legend on both sides of the globe which is rare indeed.

Doogal, medals is not a sign of greatness. It is a contributory factor, but it is a non sequitar to conclude that it is medals alone that show how good a player is.

As it was anyway, Ward won a Premier's medal with manly so can rightly conclude to have won the highest club accolade in the game.

Maybe removing the St Helens and centering the badge?

Thing is, I've tried to include a spectrum, something everyone will find something to recognise.

Like I said, I'm open to changing it for the best