I dunno I suppose we could ask Dane Carlaw for his opinion..... if he's woke up yet.

I'd say that's put that one to bed tvoc!

knee too head . same height as burrows

Quality geekery.

Bravo sir.

Do you ever post on this board sober?

Quite. That was based on the crowd reaction. Hence no Card.

The ref didnt think it was a pen otherwise he would have blown up straight away, he either listened to crowd and gave pen after burrow went off, or he was told to by upstairs.
The manly player quite clearly got him round the shoulder first contact, his arm slid up as burrow slid down.
It was a monster hit and perfectly legal, I had one almost identical last week, when player went off dazed I simply said play ball last tackle, players parents and coaches said it was high but if you listen to crowd all time then you might as well let them ref the game, just cos a player goes down and arm is near neck area doesnt mean it is.

How simplistic.

I have a simplistic view also that Jason 'Manilow' Robinson wouldn't recognise a serious head shot even if he was on the receiving end of it.

Neither does it mean that it isn't and IMO Watmough's challenge was around the players head and therefore illegal.

Don't confuse him with facts...