PAUL M wrote:Still stands, rather have Hall at FB than Byrne
Its down to personal preference, as i said last week i can see the benefits of both. Byrne effectively won us the game with his defensive work. Hall could maybe have played and won us the game with a couple of tries, who knows. After Byrnes display one thing is for sure, Motu doesnt come straight back in for Celtic if fit.
Joined: Oct 15 2003 Posts: 53839 Location: North Yorkshire
Big Dave T wrote:Its down to personal preference, as i said last week i can see the benefits of both. Byrne effectively won us the game with his defensive work. Hall could maybe have played and won us the game with a couple of tries, who knows. After Byrnes display one thing is for sure, Motu doesnt come straight back in for Celtic if fit.
Tough decision for Agar, I don't think Tony will be ready this week.
Joined: Jan 23 2006 Posts: 15980 Location: Boulevard with my balls of steel!
Big Dave T wrote:Its down to personal preference, as i said last week i can see the benefits of both. Byrne effectively won us the game with his defensive work. Hall could maybe have played and won us the game with a couple of tries, who knows. After Byrnes display one thing is for sure, Motu doesnt come straight back in for Celtic if fit.
The only reason I wouldn't is that he clearly wont be fully fit. Motu is the better player.
Robbo4 wrote:The only reason I wouldn't is that he clearly wont be fully fit. Motu is the better player.
Motu is 1000% the better player. Motu cannot though walk back into the first 13 after someone has played like Byrne did. Good selection headaches to have but you cant drop a top performer from the week before, it will stink if it happens.
I'd have Motu on the bench and shuffle things around for the last 20 if we are comfortable enough. (may even give Motu 20 at 9 to just get some game time)
Joined: Jan 23 2006 Posts: 15980 Location: Boulevard with my balls of steel!
Big Dave T wrote:Motu is 1000% the better player. Motu cannot though walk back into the first 13 after someone has played like Byrne did. Good selection headaches to have but you cant drop a top performer from the week before, it will stink if it happens.
I'd have Motu on the bench and shuffle things around for the last 20 if we are comfortable enough. (may even give Motu 20 at 9 to just get some game time)
Personally I think the performance of Byrne is being over-stated.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
