Lord_Percy wrote:Given that, how do you record the line-up's from 2007 when Diskin was out, such as Millenium Magic? I've got the teamsheet for that game and it states that Kirke was playing at hooker, but I always thought Sinfield covered that role during the games.
I'm from the Roy Walker school of 'say what you see.'
My MM pack from 2007 reads:
Kylie Leuluai, Kevin Sinfield, Jamie Thackray
Jamie Jones-Buchanan, Ian Kirke, Gareth Ellis
Extract from the YEP match report:
"Ali Lauitiiti limped off early on and Ian Kirke – named at hooker, playing in the second-row – and Kylie Leuluai battled through despite head wounds."
Dunemann and Sinfield, Dunemann and Burrow were OK but when it was Dunemann and McGuire they could be either or and often were. I usually waited for the 1st scrum to determine who was the starting SH.
I take the view that keeping unofficial records allows me some latitude. It's only ever a dispute over the split between starting positions, nothing worse than that.
