WWW.RLFANS.COM :: View topic - Wrestling in the tackle

Forever FC wrote:I think the PTB needed to be slowed down IMO (maybe not this way though) a return to the 5 metre rule might of been better?. the fact that in the last 5 or so years we have seen teams with 2 hookers scooting from the play the ball has brought the skill level down as teams have stopped having to create things. give it time and we may see a return to the handling skills that made our game the greatest on earth.

Captain Dave wrote:An effort by the RFL to slow may well also reduce injuries at at the collision.
As you say the introduction of the 10m rule has seen the reduction in the number of ball handling players and is the biggest change of the modern game.

robinho wrote:Wrestling in the tackle will slowly kill the game as a spectacle. As a speccie at all our games it is dire to watch, so for all neutrals and armchair viewers it cannot be conduicive to a good watch in the hope of attracting new supporters to the game.

The usual inconsistency in how the refs apply the rule also leaves a lot to be desired which means the game descends into a series of 5 drives and a kick.

It is also no coicidence that as wrestling has become the current trend, there appears to be more chicken wing tackles as opposing players attempt to slow down the PTB.

This whole tactic needs stamping out.

Gordon Gekko wrote:Anybody notice the attempted one on Vella by O'Loughlin???

Author:	Wildmoose [ Sun Sep 27, 2009 3:13 pm ]
Post subject:	Wrestling in the tackle
So now we’ve had a full season of the new interpretations, what do we think? This has been our biggest area of weakness this season IMO & something we definitely need to work on. We’ve been wrestled to death at times & the result has often been slower PTBs than we were getting in the national leagues. Maybe a direct consequence of opting for a smaller & more mobile pack? It certainly favours the bigger, more physical sides. This isn’t just about Rovers though, it’s up to us to adapt. The balance between speed & physicality certainly needed looking at, but overall have the RFL got this right or not? Will we still see players like Burrow & Eastmond in the future if we go too far down this route? Huddersfield v Catalans on Friday was awful to watch, despite both sides having some great players. Is this the future of our game? I hope not.

Author:	hullbg [ Sun Sep 27, 2009 10:39 pm ]
Post subject:
It has been awful this season, and not just from a Hull point of view. The PTB has been slowed down so much the game has become very boring at times. With the slowing of the PTB teams have started to rely even heavier on kicks to create tries, wheras in the past good fast PTB's put a defence on the back foot and gaps started to appear. My humble opinion.

Author:	Forever FC [ Sun Sep 27, 2009 10:43 pm ]
Post subject:
I think the PTB needed to be slowed down IMO (maybe not this way though) a return to the 5 metre rule might of been better?. the fact that in the last 5 or so years we have seen teams with 2 hookers scooting from the play the ball has brought the skill level down as teams have stopped having to create things. give it time and we may see a return to the handling skills that made our game the greatest on earth.

Author:	hullbg [ Sun Sep 27, 2009 11:11 pm ]
Post subject:
We slowed it down because of the international game. We had a far better spectator sport than the NRL a few years back. Not sure if you watched NRL then but it was just a dour battle with defences always on top. Now if you put the two leagues side by side we look a million miles away from them.

Author:	Captain Dave [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 6:30 am ]
Post subject:
Forever FC wrote:I think the PTB needed to be slowed down IMO (maybe not this way though) a return to the 5 metre rule might of been better?. the fact that in the last 5 or so years we have seen teams with 2 hookers scooting from the play the ball has brought the skill level down as teams have stopped having to create things. give it time and we may see a return to the handling skills that made our game the greatest on earth. An effort by the RFL to slow may well also reduce injuries at at the collision. As you say the introduction of the 10m rule has seen the reduction in the number of ball handling players and is the biggest change of the modern game.

WWW.RLFANS.COM https://rlfans.com/forums/

Wrestling in the tackle https://rlfans.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=59&t=431951	Page 1 of 3

Author:	rover49 [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 6:46 am ]
Post subject:
Captain Dave wrote:An effort by the RFL to slow may well also reduce injuries at at the collision. As you say the introduction of the 10m rule has seen the reduction in the number of ball handling players and is the biggest change of the modern game. When did that come in, I have seen 7m, 8m but rarely seen ten. They should name it the the 'referees flexible rule'

Author:	robinho [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 9:20 am ]
Post subject:
Wrestling in the tackle will slowly kill the game as a spectacle. As a speccie at all our games it is dire to watch, so for all neutrals and armchair viewers it cannot be conduicive to a good watch in the hope of attracting new supporters to the game. The usual inconsistency in how the refs apply the rule also leaves a lot to be desired which means the game descends into a series of 5 drives and a kick. It is also no coicidence that as wrestling has become the current trend, there appears to be more chicken wing tackles as opposing players attempt to slow down the PTB. This whole tactic needs stamping out.

Author:	Gordon Gekko [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 9:22 am ]
Post subject:
robinho wrote:Wrestling in the tackle will slowly kill the game as a spectacle. As a speccie at all our games it is dire to watch, so for all neutrals and armchair viewers it cannot be conduicive to a good watch in the hope of attracting new supporters to the game. The usual inconsistency in how the refs apply the rule also leaves a lot to be desired which means the game descends into a series of 5 drives and a kick. It is also no coicidence that as wrestling has become the current trend, there appears to be more chicken wing tackles as opposing players attempt to slow down the PTB. This whole tactic needs stamping out. Anybody notice the attempted one on Vella by O'Loughlin???

Author:	Staffs FC [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 10:04 am ]
Post subject:
Gordon Gekko wrote:Anybody notice the attempted one on Vella by O'Loughlin??? There's loads of it in the game now Galea tried one on Coley as well. A few lengthy bans should be meted out that would soon stop it.

Author:	robinho [ Mon Sep 28, 2009 10:30 am ]
Post subject:
Gordon My post wasn't suggesting we were innocent of this. It's something that is creeping into the game as a whole which is not necessary. It's a hard enough game as it is without those tactics coming into it aswell. Staffs FC Correct, lengthy bans might put a stop to it, but given that JJB's effort on the Ginger one only warranted (in the RFL's eyes) a one match ban, I would be surprised if Vella and Galea have any case to answer. Then again, they don't play for Leeds....

Page 1 of 3	All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/