Joined: Mar 05 2007 Posts: 13190 Location: Hedon (sometimes), sometimes Premier Inn's
Mr. Zucchini Head wrote:Shows what a big factor club bias is. You guys have already had their say about Calderwood, but if you were offered Briscoe, or even Reece Lyne who looks an excellent prospect, who you still keep Colbon over them?
Bias has nowt to do with it with me, I think Colbon is a better alround player than Calderwood. I would have Berrigan over any of our hookers and Briscoe (as a centre) over Welham. You have a few players who I would like in a Rovers shirt at the expense of some of ours, but Calderwood isn't one of them.
'when my life is over, the thing which will have given me greatest pride is that I was first to plunge into the sea, swimming freely underwater without any connection to the terrestrial world'
rover49 wrote:Bias has nowt to do with it with me, I think Colbon is a better alround player than Calderwood. I would have Berrigan over any of our hookers and Briscoe (as a centre) over Welham. You have a few players who I would like in a Rovers shirt at the expense of some of ours, but Calderwood isn't one of them.
I wasn't talking about just your fans being biased, all fans are biased towards their own players to some respect. Even last year when you were having a great season I would have been able to count on one hand the players from you that I would want at Hull. If the roles are reversed this year and we are at the top you will probably say the same thing. Personally I think Calderwood is everything you could ask from a winger and is well suited to our side. Very fast, reasonably good in the air, bags of enthusiasm and energy, we don't really need a winger who can come and help the forwards out because the forwards are very strong this year (although Briscoe is like another forward when he carries it in). You on the other hand don't have such a big pack and so Fox and Colbon are expected to carry the ball alot.
The only players I would take from your squad becasue I believe they would improve us are:
Fox (competing with Calderwood for right centre spot) Dobson (back up for Long/ competing with Horne for stand off) Galea (ahead of Tickle) Murrell (good utility value)
You have plenty of good players but I don't think they would either be suited to us or be better than what we've got.
Mr. Zucchini Head wrote:I wasn't talking about just your fans being biased, all fans are biased towards their own players to some respect. Even last year when you were having a great season I would have been able to count on one hand the players from you that I would want at Hull. If the roles are reversed this year and we are at the top you will probably say the same thing. Personally I think Calderwood is everything you could ask from a winger and is well suited to our side. Very fast, reasonably good in the air, bags of enthusiasm and energy, we don't really need a winger who can come and help the forwards out because the forwards are very strong this year (although Briscoe is like another forward when he carries it in). You on the other hand don't have such a big pack and so Fox and Colbon are expected to carry the ball alot.
The only players I would take from your squad becasue I believe they would improve us are:
Fox (competing with Calderwood for right centre spot) Dobson (back up for Long/ competing with Horne for stand off) Galea (ahead of Tickle) Murrell (good utility value)
You have plenty of good players but I don't think they would either be suited to us or be better than what we've got.
Mr. Zucchini Head wrote:I wasn't talking about just your fans being biased, all fans are biased towards their own players to some respect. Even last year when you were having a great season I would have been able to count on one hand the players from you that I would want at Hull. If the roles are reversed this year and we are at the top you will probably say the same thing. Personally I think Calderwood is everything you could ask from a winger and is well suited to our side. Very fast, reasonably good in the air, bags of enthusiasm and energy, we don't really need a winger who can come and help the forwards out because the forwards are very strong this year (although Briscoe is like another forward when he carries it in). You on the other hand don't have such a big pack and so Fox and Colbon are expected to carry the ball alot.
The only players I would take from your squad becasue I believe they would improve us are:
Fox (competing with Calderwood for right centre spot) Dobson (back up for Long/ competing with Horne for stand off) Galea (ahead of Tickle) Murrell (good utility value)
You have plenty of good players but I don't think they would either be suited to us or be better than what we've got.
Briscoe at FB (you know you would over Tansey), and however much you dislike him because he's God to us Rovers fans; Clint Newton (best SR in the comp last year speaks for itself).
Joined: Mar 05 2007 Posts: 13190 Location: Hedon (sometimes), sometimes Premier Inn's
moxi1 wrote:Briscoe at FB (you know you would over Tansey), and however much you dislike him because he's God to us Rovers fans; Clint Newton (best SR in the comp last year speaks for itself).
They got rid of Briscoe because he's rubbish
I'd have Newton over there 2nd rows (Fitzgibbon was class, but lets see how he goes) anyday.
'when my life is over, the thing which will have given me greatest pride is that I was first to plunge into the sea, swimming freely underwater without any connection to the terrestrial world'
Mr. Zucchini Head wrote:I wasn't talking about just your fans being biased, all fans are biased towards their own players to some respect. Even last year when you were having a great season I would have been able to count on one hand the players from you that I would want at Hull. If the roles are reversed this year and we are at the top you will probably say the same thing. Personally I think Calderwood is everything you could ask from a winger and is well suited to our side. Very fast, reasonably good in the air, bags of enthusiasm and energy, we don't really need a winger who can come and help the forwards out because the forwards are very strong this year (although Briscoe is like another forward when he carries it in). You on the other hand don't have such a big pack and so Fox and Colbon are expected to carry the ball alot.
The only players I would take from your squad becasue I believe they would improve us are:
Fox (competing with Calderwood for right centre spot) Dobson (back up for Long/ competing with Horne for stand off) Galea (ahead of Tickle) Murrell (good utility value)
You have plenty of good players but I don't think they would either be suited to us or be better than what we've got.
wouldnt touch him...his tackling percentage is awful....he does attempt alot of tackles and yes he makes alot but he was top of the misses stats..but would defo take the other lot
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 92 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
