Fitzhenry hasn't been so bad, but I've not noticed Walker do anything in 18 months to justify us signing him. Just my opinion, but I don't feel he's contributed anything different to what a young upcoming player would have done.
If I was Justin I would def have chose Cockayne over Walker for Sat, no comparison in terms of heart and enthusiasm.

Tbh although I don't rate Cockayne very highly ability wise, he certainly makes up for that in effort, and I for one am quite pleased to see him excluded from the squad.

Wasn't he dropped last time around too?

[quote="Stan Butler"]Wasn't he dropped last time around too?[/quote]

Aint sure but I'd certainly rather Chev Walker was playing

Says it all really!

The trouble with Ben is he has a knack of undoing all he's good at with a rush of blood and giving away a string of pens that totally kill us. Fitzy has been improving at hooker and has played really well over the last few weeks.

Walker looks good in short spells, just doesn;t look fit and is blowing after 15mins and starts to miss tackles. I'm assuming he's picked walker over Ben as Walker can cover 2nd row as well as centre.

Agreed. Chev has not lived up to the reputation he had and I don't think there's been one game where he really stood out, has he ever had MOM?

I understand that not everyone in the squad can fit into the match day 17, but can anyone tell me what Ben has done that merits dropping out of the 17 when Fitzy and Chev are in?

Fitzy has scored a few tries lately, well good for him, but that does not necessarily mean he's had a good game. He's in the squad now and no doubt will spend more time at Hooker than our Hooker will so I hope he has a stormer but don't tell me he offers more than Charlie week in week out because that's nonsense!

It's our little guys that will do most of the damage.

Hull only have 3 props in their squad, including King & Moa, who are short stint players with poor lateral movement....they'd have had a mare against Charlie.

Can't help thinking Justin's missed a trick here.

Almost certain he's never been MOM mate. Tbh I reckon the union stint killed him (similar to the way it did Harris).

Agree totally about Cockayne - thought he was excellent standing in at full-back last week, and certainly adds more versatility to the squad then Fitz or Walker, but clearly Morgan must like/rate them both higher.

For me Walker can cause more damage up the middle with his size(i know he hasn't in parts) than what charlie can whilst fitzhenry is probably more consistant in the hooking role than charlie usually making better decisions (or less brain explosions you decide ).

I understand the possible thinking and in most parts agree but its a good thing to have a very good squad player like charlie.