He maybe taller but he's not better, the way he bounced of Yeaman was criminal. Websters positional sense isn't always the best but when he does make a tackle it generally sticks.

Yes Webster can tackle. Trouble is he tends to end up down injured each time he makes one.

Trouble is though, yes if it was a comparison of Jake Webster 2008 vs Craig Hall 2011 then fair dues Webbo would prob win, but unfortunately because of all the injuries he's a pale imitation of who he was IMO, whereas Hall I still feel will get better yet, and in any case offers us plenty in attack. Okay his defence maybe needs work, but the talent and potential is there, so I'd give him the position permanantly tbh.

Last season I would have agreed with you, but I think he's been much better, apart from when he is genuinely injured as he was against Wigan. But he does seem to have cut out the staying down after every tackle, which to be honest was really starting to get on my wick last year.

Apart from what people say on here regards his defence I've not really seen enough of him to pass judgement, I like his attitude and hope he gets a regular spot so we can all see either way, seem's a waste sat in the reserves.