Joined: Jul 15 2005 Posts: 29803 Location: West Yorkshire
Can't see that Kelly will have passed any head test yesterday so unless new injuries picked up I think it will be Manu in Kelly out, could be:
Shaul Faraimo Carlos Griffin Tuimavave Connor Sneyd Watts Hadley Paea Mini Manu Bowden
Green Fash Washbrook Abdull
The other question is whether the game will go ahead with the apocalyptic snow forecasts. Seem to remember it's less the pitch, more Health and Safety concerns about the paths etc round the ground that are the risk.
Joined: Nov 20 2011 Posts: 1183 Location: Australia
Mrs Barista wrote:Can't see that Kelly will have passed any head test yesterday so unless new injuries picked up I think it will be Manu in Kelly out, could be:
Shaul Faraimo Carlos Griffin Tuimavave Connor Sneyd Watts Hadley Paea Mini Manu Bowden
Green Fash Washbrook Abdull
The other question is whether the game will go ahead with the apocalyptic snow forecasts. Seem to remember it's less the pitch, more Health and Safety concerns about the paths etc round the ground that are the risk.
Suggest you incude Talanoa unless CT can play in 2 positions at the same time!
Mrs Barista wrote:Can't see that Kelly will have passed any head test yesterday so unless new injuries picked up I think it will be Manu in Kelly out, could be:
Shaul Faraimo Carlos Griffin Tuimavave Connor Sneyd Watts Hadley Paea Mini Manu Bowden
Green Fash Washbrook Abdull
The other question is whether the game will go ahead with the apocalyptic snow forecasts. Seem to remember it's less the pitch, more Health and Safety concerns about the paths etc round the ground that are the risk.
I reckon Kelly will play. Fairamo was ko'd against Wigan and he played against St George. If he is fit, I'd go with Connor and Carlos in the centres, I keep convincing myself Griffin is due a big game but he never seems to produce the goods, apart from the odd half here and there.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25900 Location: Back in Hull.
Id like to see Abdul at LF from the off to improve our attacking structure, Cas were so much slicker with their ball movement our wide and I think having Abdul there would improve this for us.
Washy on the bench to cover hooker as I think Hadley needs a break (And can also cover the backrow).
If Kelly is fit, there would be no place for Griffin in my 17.
The last thing we want is Washbrook at hooker, even if Hadley is fooked he'd be quicker and more effective than Washbrook. Rather have Abdul on at 13 from the off and have Bowden on the bench as a prop with Green, Masi and Fash. Currently Fash offers more than Washbrook.
Joined: Feb 09 2004 Posts: 7735 Location: Here there and everywhere
knockersbumpMKII wrote:The last thing we want is Washbrook at hooker, even if Hadley is fooked he'd be quicker and more effective than Washbrook. Rather have Abdul on at 13 from the off and have Bowden on the bench as a prop with Green, Masi and Fash. Currently Fash offers more than Washbrook.
Tend to agree with this. For all of Washbrooks versatility which has been well utilised in the past two seasons, he does not look anywhere near effective enough to maintain a place in the 17 for me. Granted he does not let you down, he has a safe pair of hands and rarely gets penalised, I feel this is no longer enough if we want to be at the upper end of the table.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25900 Location: Back in Hull.
Mild mannered Janitor wrote:Tend to agree with this. For all of Washbrooks versatility which has been well utilised in the past two seasons, he does not look anywhere near effective enough to maintain a place in the 17 for me. Granted he does not let you down, he has a safe pair of hands and rarely gets penalised, I feel this is no longer enough if we want to be at the upper end of the table.
I agree, decent squad player, but not in our first 17, in fact there would have to be a few injuries for him to get a game (like on Saturday)
However with Houghton out I think he is useful to have on the bench to give Hadley a break, he did a decent job of covering there last season, personally I would prefer to see Litten given a bench spot, but I don't see Radford doing that.
Washbrook currently has the worst missed tackle rate out of the whole squad, he's made a paltry 68 metres at 5.7m per carry and is up there with the top error makers aside from Connor who has double the next person I just don't see Washbrook as being 'safe' at this moment in time, he's a tryer but he's well short currently as are some others. Litten should be in front if we are wanting to relieve Hadley in any case.
I realise Washbrook hasn't had as much game time as some (which magnifies his error number though) but it just goes to show that we should be looking to someone else to have a go at filling his slot/role if Radford is sticking to his mandate of picking players on form.
Which should see some players under pressure, I reckon Logan could be given a run in the centres if others aren't up to the mark, I can't see Shaul being dropped though. The stand outs so far for me are Hadley and Paea with Abdul not far behind.
We deffo need to sort out bench out though because that was a baffling choice on Saturday if I'm honest, it left us well short of grunt.
knockersbumpMKII wrote:We deffo need to sort out bench out though because that was a baffling choice on Saturday if I'm honest, it left us well short of grunt.
Houghton, Taylor, Manu missing and Green's partner expecting a baby anytime soon, who's this player with "grunt" you'd have picked?
Is Hodgson the new Griffin, or is it all about pace?
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum