What in earth went wrong for him at Hull FC?
I was worried when we signed him after some of his later performances for you, but he has been one of our best players this year. His defence in particular has been outstanding, particularly last night against the Leeds back line.

From the games I've said he has been stronger in defence , he scored some great try's for hull, which I haven't seen him do yet at Cas.

Think he had an attitude problem at Hull, certainly got some good talent though

His defence has definitely improved since he left us, but he was also unfairly singled out at Hull because he was never that bad a defender. I think he simply didn't fit into Radford's philosophy. Had Peter Gentle not left (or had we got another coach who took a more adventurous approach) I'm sure he'd still be here.

Glad to see him doing well for you guys though.

Well, watching the game last week against Warrington, he was doing a very good impression of a turnstile most of the game.

I think you could say that about every Cas player that evening, we were just pulled everywhere by Sandow and Warrington took advantage all over the field.

Sometimes a player needs a change of club to improve . To early to say whether he's going to be a top signing but that's sport.

Possibly so, but I've been waiting for a thread on this topic to come up, and on what little I've seen of him this year, he's not shown that he's over his defensive frailties, yet.
I hope he does improve, and goes on to be the player he has the potential to be.

Liked Ben Crooks a a lot. On meeting he was a down to earth nice freindly kid and didnt come across as having an attitude problem at all - the exact opposite of Lineham who seemed a total lover at that time

Well, we have played two live games on sky where he has shown no defensive frailties. Obviously, when you see highlight you only see tries scored, not ones prevented. At Warrington we were all over the place as a team. In all other games he has been solid.
What we haven't seen too much of is his attacking threat.

Well when we played you Carlos had been ripping everyone apart and Crooks did a really good job on him.