bonaire wrote:You seriously think he needs more time to get over his achilles injury? McIntosh seems to be OK,Cator was all over the pitch until his repeat injury. Sorry but you are making excuses for him His continual poor defence and positioning has nothing to do with his past injury
bonaire wrote:You seriously think he needs more time to get over his achilles injury? McIntosh seems to be OK,Cator was all over the pitch until his repeat injury. Sorry but you are making excuses for him His continual poor defence and positioning has nothing to do with his past injury
McIntosh has had issues with his calf and obviously we all saw what happened to cator it does look like it could be weighing on his mind a bit just doesn't seem as confident in his own ability at the moment. Although a different injury I think, shaul looks the shadow of the player he was pre injury
bonaire wrote:You seriously think he needs more time to get over his achilles injury? McIntosh seems to be OK,Cator was all over the pitch until his repeat injury. Sorry but you are making excuses for him His continual poor defence and positioning has nothing to do with his past injury
Im making no excuses, just pointing out that publically slating a player out of form wont help him get his form and confidence back.
Joined: Sep 14 2009 Posts: 1606 Location: on route to old trafford via wembley
Woods1969 wrote:McIntosh has had issues with his calf and obviously we all saw what happened to cator it does look like it could be weighing on his mind a bit just doesn't seem as confident in his own ability at the moment. Although a different injury I think, shaul looks the shadow of the player he was pre injury
Is that what was wrong with him, I thought someone had put cement in his boots.
pmarrow wrote:Im making no excuses, just pointing out that publically slating a player out of form wont help him get his form and confidence back.
I dont see how you think this would help.
All i can say is Tony Smith has done it with Sims saying he was dropped and then played him in the reserves. Dont get what the problem is. Are you saying it might hurt his feelings if dropped and have to play in the reserves rather than a stimulus to regain his place in the first team.
bonaire wrote:All i can say is Tony Smith has done it with Sims saying he was dropped and then played him in the reserves. Dont get what the problem is. Are you saying it might hurt his feelings if dropped and have to play in the reserves rather than a stimulus to regain his place in the first team.
Again, I dont know why you think its important BH says it in the media. Why is that so important ?
Also the Tony Smith sutuation is different, for a start he doesnt have 10000 cry babies after every loss.
Joined: Sep 14 2009 Posts: 1606 Location: on route to old trafford via wembley
pmarrow wrote:All I can say is, im glad alot of you arent given the reigns at our club.
I don't think my point was that bad. It makes sense to me that a player with zero confidence would be better suited somewhere else rather than in Hull FC's first team.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum