Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25935 Location: Back in Hull.
Jake the Peg wrote:I'm never wrong, ask my wife.
Anyway, back to your selection, you'd play players out of position and leave out our most effective winger? Are you peter gentle or richard agar?
Talanoa our most effective winger, not sure I agree, too slow, poor defensively and poor under the high ball, Fonua is a better winger IMO. Talanoa is great at making yards but I'd like more from my winger, you talk about our backs being slow then big up Talanoa
Joined: Feb 19 2009 Posts: 1957 Location: East stand!
Dave K. wrote:As yet he isn't doing quite enough going forward to outweigh his defence, but it's early days yet.
I thought he played well on the wing one game this year went Talanoa went off (Saints)
At one point I'd like to see this as our backs
Fonua Carlos Connor Griffin
Griffin is among our best metre men. 9 plus metres a carry. Far in front of anyone else in the backs Not his fault our attack has been lacking to really release him. For a half v wigan we were flowing and he had gelling on toast Defensively he ain't gonna be as good as yeamo. Few are. But I've found most of what he's been blamed for a bit laughable. A winger got 3 tries scored outside of him and it was griffins fault? Salford he was gash granted. But so was everyone. The left side is much the same as the right last yr. It's a bit out of sync but I've not seen too many one on one misses. A couple stand out but I've also seen Mini and Sneyd do it too
Joined: Feb 19 2009 Posts: 1957 Location: East stand!
Dave K. wrote:Talanoa our most effective winger, not sure I agree, too slow, poor defensively and poor under the high ball, Fonua is a better winger IMO. Talanoa is great at making yards but I'd like more from my winger, you talk about our backs being slow then big up Talanoa
Personally I can't fathom what you've been watching for 3 years. He's even won our player of the year in that time
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25935 Location: Back in Hull.
airliebird,runninglate! wrote:Personally I can't fathom what you've been watching for 3 years. He's even won our player of the year in that time
We have moved on since then IMO, I think he is an OK winger, but to continue to challenge I think we need better, although not sure there will be better available so he might end up staying. To be honest he will stay as Radford really rates him.
Joined: Mar 14 2003 Posts: 25935 Location: Back in Hull.
airliebird,runninglate! wrote:Griffin is among our best metre men. 9 plus metres a carry. Far in front of anyone else in the backs Not his fault our attack has been lacking to really release him. For a half v wigan we were flowing and he had gelling on toast Defensively he ain't gonna be as good as yeamo. Few are. But I've found most of what he's been blamed for a bit laughable. A winger got 3 tries scored outside of him and it was griffins fault? Salford he was gash granted. But so was everyone. The left side is much the same as the right last yr. It's a bit out of sync but I've not seen too many one on one misses. A couple stand out but I've also seen Mini and Sneyd do it too
As I've said it early days, but he has cost us a few try's and although great in the first half against Wigan he was playing against an injured Gelling.
Mini will always miss tackles with the anmount of work he has to do and plays too many minutes, Sneyd like most halfs struggles at times with his defence.
Hopefully Griffin will improve as I feel he has real potential.
Joined: Aug 01 2005 Posts: 5916 Location: Definately not in the Cuddle Crew
airliebird,runninglate! wrote:Personally I can't fathom what you've been watching for 3 years. He's even won our player of the year in that time
Agreed - Talanoa isnt perfect but hes a very good player - what player is 100% in all areas? If he was he'd be on top dollar in the NRL so i really dont get peoples critisism
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
