tristram wrote:Ha, I can't count how many times people say 'its a try' when they believe it isn't and hope that the VR says it's not -- pessimists the lot of us! (Having said that I've seen the VR make totally bonkers decisions on too many occasions to have much faith in them getting it right! Having said that, I think the current scheme is better than previous one, at least the ref has to say how he would call it.)
yeh agree , but it shouldnt have any influence if its an actual try or not, crazy decisions given because ref as given the try on the field or not given it
I'm wanting to see a Cas v Hull FC final. Whilst I'd like Hull to beat Leeds tonight, I'd definitely rather beat the pies next week (and keep them out of the semi) as that feeds into my other scheme which is to have all-Yorkshire finals
The run up to the semi's...
Code:
Castleford: Huddersfield (a), Leeds (h), Wigan (a), Hull FC (h) Huddersfield: Castleford (h), Salford (a), St Helens (a), Leeds (h). Hull FC: Leeds (a), Wigan (h), Wakefield (h), Castleford (a). Leeds: Hull FC (h), Castleford (a), Salford (h), Huddersfield (a) Salford: Wakefield (h), Huddersfield (h), Leeds (a), St Helens (h). St Helens: Wigan (h), Wakefield (a), Huddersfield (h), Salford (a) Wakefield: Salford (a), St Helens (h), Hull FC (a), Wigan (h). Wigan: St Helens (a), Hull FC (a), Castleford (h), Wakefield (a).
Hasbag wrote:Never a try. Watkins got a hand to that and knocked it into Briscoe. One angle showed it pretty clearly but the video ref never picked up on it.
Yep , never even looked at it, only phil clarke called it, considering ref called no try for a knock on, hard to believe didnt even look at watkins knocking it in to briscoe
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
