I personally think Minichello is more invaluable than Ellis, Ellis is a great leader but Mini does everything he does and a little bit more.
Admittedly he does miss a few more tackles but like yesterday he was first one to the saints player catching the bomb, would love to have seen him level the winger but mistimed it

Ellis is consistent, week in, week out.

I disagree totally. We are noticeably a different team when Ellis is off the field, even yesterday 2 tries were scored during his short spell on the sidelines.

I love mini don't get me wrong. But we are 2 different teams with Ellis and without him

Both fantastic players, great to have such strenght in the pack, many fans including me though we might have the balance of our squad wrong, but the strenght in the pack is the reason for our success.

Well played. Men against boys. Mullered us up the middle. Good luck for the rest of the cup.

Regards

Tail between his legs

King James

Dear me,I like Mini,but Ellis is twice the player,he is still world class.

Privileged to have both,amongst others..good times

Yes but you would have got the 74 with him playing for us.

... there was a (heated) debate about Turner earlier in this thread... viewtopic.php?p=18349682#p18349682

... there was a (heated) debate about Turner earlier in this thread... viewtopic.php?p=18349682#p18349682