I must say what really annoyed me about this was that Ellis knew he hadn't scored, he was trying to get up and carry on quick before Wigan could get themselves set and composed.

Thaler sent it upstairs even though he thought himself that it was no try. If you think its no try and the player clearly does then let the game go on. By stopping it even though he knew it wasn't a score then it gave Wigan a chance to get back into line and have a breather. We could well have been in next play if it weren't for that.

Anyway, doesn't matter one bit, just an observation!

At the time I said if Wigan had had it disallowed I'd have been fuming as it did look to creep over, but Ellis gave himself up and even said on his player-mic "it was short, no try" - too honest for his own good!

On the other hand, Tierney had a try disallowed for a forward pass that everyone seemed to agree was a bad call so it's swings and roundabouts.

Looked a try after Ellis had done exactly what hicks said he could do and propelled the ball forward whilst under possession. I wasn't surprised when it wasn't given though. Not in the slightest.

I don't agree that it was a bad call and I also thought the pass for your 2nd try was forward. Doesn't matter as we won but we did seem to get some poor calls against us last night

Clearest forward pass of the evening. Poor execution on that one.

As a neutral I thought the VR had no choice but to stay with the on-field call. Overall I thought Hull were badly done to on the penalties with some of the interference ones being ridiculous in comparison to the way Wigan mess around at the PTB.

Anyway, the right team won so well done and enjoy the final.

I wasn't a try. From the angles on TV it simply wasn't it was a fraction too short.
It went up as a no try and conclusive proof was needed for it to be given.

I think if ellis had jumped up celebrating and thrown the ball in the air he'd have given it, as it was, ellis got up to play the ball so no surprise thaler didn't give it

ok that looks conclusive - but the zoomed image was not shown in TV ...