Andy Gilder wrote:Since they shifted Braylon Edwards, being Cleveland's best player is hardly a glowing recommendation.
He's effective out of the Wildcat and returning kicks but offers little as a genuine WR. How much should you pay someone like that?
Edwards was terrible after the one good season he had. He couldn't catch a cold (i accept having rubbish QB's doesn't help).
Cribbs is excellent on returning kicks, but he is also IIRC the top special teams tackler on the Browns and the gunner on punts. He is a better overall special teams player than Hester when he was playing special teams. He has 400 rushing yards, is an effective wildcat player, a decent 3rd or 4th reciever and actually taken a few pass attempts. His play alone has won them games. Like Hester in his day havng him back there means teams will kick it away from him giving better field position.
By all accounts he is a key guy in the locker room, was promised a new deal before Mangini came in and didn't get it, was promiseed another one when Holmgren signed and this was the offer.
It's a difficult one to say what to pay him, personally i think he's worth $3-5 per year (potentially parity with Hester?? (although i don't know what he's on)) and i'd be looking to get as high as a 2nd round draft pick for him.