no disrespect to young tomkins,he needs a bit more time,but tonights match prooved that we are lacking a seasoned stand off.

The lad is quality but he's playing within himself a little at the moment. He's not taking the line on enough which really is his strong suit.

I really do hope it's just early career nerves holding his running game back and not Noble.

i thought he did nt play bad

Disappointed we played Mcillorum instead of Smith, tonight was made for his cut out passess.

A bit harsh the lad didn't let anyone down and he had the bollox to try thing's i.e little chip kicks,took the line on and didn't get caught out in defence.
Just out of interest what did you expect????

I think Tomkins had a fairly good game tonight, he can't win every game on his own, i will say it again I would of liked to of seen Smith out there tonight off the bench. Leuluai needed to step up as well to put the whole of our hopes on Sam is just plain stupid.

To me Eastmond is much more suited to SL at the moment than Tomkins. In my opinion the exposure to first team last year has pushed him ahead of Tomkins, hopefully we will reap the rewards later in the year and future more than Saints will from Eastmond.

On the plus side it does look like we have 2 quality halves who have the potential to be anything in the game.

As a saints fan I think in two seasons time he will prove a worthy asset. He is a keeper. Don't sell this one to buy an aging Aussie import

to keep the present squad i would put phelps at stand off and bring young tomkins on as and when.

Some very harsh comments here. He seems the real deal to me. I can see a future england half back partnership with eastmond at 6. He will be world class if coached well (send him our way if you like ). Top class