Father Ted wrote:Wouldn't anyone prefer McGuire to Lam? He's taken charge of the Storm, not Kearney, when Bellamy has been away with Origin.
Lam has been at the Roosters which has fallen apart this last few years.
A reminder too that bringing back a former player, however good, doesn't always work as head coach. I'd go for McGuire with his own asst.
Whichever IL goes for, a new coach now or 2011 the appointment of Noble's successor will have to be made early. IL was non committal over the coaching position at the FF yet said there maybe no new signings for next year. If he still thinks we can go with the same squad and no new players after last Saturday then we are in bigger trouble than we think.
He may of course not be saying anything due to the 1st Sept deadline for British players and not announcing anything re overseas signings until their season is over.
In answer to your first question, yes - I'd much prefer McGuire to Lam.
Lam is too inexperienced to take on an underperforming club like Wigan. We need someone who can take the whole playing operation by the scruff of the neck and send it in a new direction, and we need that person for the start of next year - not at some tenuous future date when Noble feels like applying for another job again, or when someone like Lam has finally learned enough to be taken a chance on.