WWW.RLFANS.COM :: View topic

19 Leagues wrote:Agree about Marsh. He's yet to prove himself for me. I'd have rather kept Pryce in our squad and sent Marsh to Quins

*opens can of worms*

Paul Youane wrote:Here's a Warrington side missing 6 of its first choice 17:

Hodgson
J. Monaghan
Bridge
King
Evans
Briers
Myler
Morley
M. Monaghan
Wood
Westwood
Harrison
Grix

Cooper
Solomona
Williams
McCarthy

Not sure that team would be "struggling big time", I'd fancy it to beat the Wigan 17 named above. Certainly the three-quarter line offers considerably more threat and fire-power.

twosevenzero wrote:I trust MM's judgement.

LewCharnock wrote:But the players you have chosen are nowhere near as vital to the Warrington team that the Wigan players currently injured are.
Sam T- best fullback (Hodgson)
Gleeson- first choice centre (King)
Richards- Best Winger- (Atkins or Monaghan, debateable which)
Finch- First choice half back (Briers)
Fielden- Best prop last season (Morley)
Take them out and yes, you would be "struggling big time".

Jeff the God of Biscuits wrote:Stole my post!

Jeff the God of Biscuits wrote:But if you look at the players missing for Wigan: 2 half backs [One being possibly the best player in the country], our [Arguably] best Prop. The Man of FN Steel. If you had say Briers & Monaghan, Morley & King out [What I would consider the corresponding players], would you still be confident of beating that Wigan 17? I think I know where my money would be.

LewCharnock wrote:Take them out and yes, you would be "struggling big time".

Paul Youane wrote:Here you go then:

Riley
Evans
Bridge
Grix
J. Monaghan
Myler
Monaghan
Carvell
Clarke
Wood
Anderson
Westwood
Harrison

Higham
Cooper
McCarthy
Solomona

I do not think that team would be "struggling big time" either.

Grimmy wrote::SLEEPY: There really should be some kind of ban on this, it's such a boring cop out. It goes without saying that we all think Mike Maguire has done a brilliant job so far, and I think this will turn out to be a smart move, but it would be a pretty boring forum if we didn't form our own opinions.

Author:	Rogues Gallery [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:04 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
19 Leagues wrote:Agree about Marsh. He's yet to prove himself for me. I'd have rather kept Pryce in our squad and sent Marsh to Quins opens can of worms It could be that Marsh still qualifies at U20 level, whereas Pryce doesn't so it allows another squad player over 20 to play in the U20 side.

Author:	LewCharnock [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:04 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
Paul Youane wrote:Here's a Warrington side missing 6 of its first choice 17: Hodgson J. Monaghan Bridge King Evans Briers Myler Morley M. Monaghan Wood Westwood Harrison Grix Cooper Solomona Williams McCarthy Not sure that team would be "struggling big time", I'd fancy it to beat the Wigan 17 named above. Certainly the three-quarter line offers considerably more threat and fire-power. But the players you have chosen are nowhere near as vital to the Warrington team that the Wigan players currently injured are. Sam T- best fullback (Hodgson) Gleeson- first choice centre (King) Richards- Best Winger- (Atkins or Monaghan, debateable which) Finch- First choice half back (Briers) Fielden- Best prop last season (Morley) Take them out and yes, you would be "struggling big time".

Author:	Grimmy [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:08 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
twosevenzero wrote:I trust MM's judgement. There really should be some kind of ban on this, it's such a boring cop out. It goes without saying that we all think Mike Maguire has done a brilliant job so far, and I think this will turn out to be a smart move, but it would be a pretty boring forum if we didn't form our own opinions.

Author:	Jeff the God of Biscuits [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:09 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
LewCharnock wrote:But the players you have chosen are nowhere near as vital to the Warrington team that the Wigan players currently injured are. Sam T- best fullback (Hodgson) Gleeson- first choice centre (King) Richards- Best Winger- (Atkins or Monaghan, debateable which) Finch- First choice half back (Briers) Fielden- Best prop last season (Morley) Take them out and yes, you would be "struggling big time". Stole my post!

Author:	LewCharnock [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
Jeff the God of Biscuits wrote:Stole my post! It's that obvious I think he needed to be told twice , although admittedly I didn't see your post

WWW.RLFANS.COM https://rlfans.com/forums/

Harrison hansen https://rlfans.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=28&t=480137	Page 3 of 4

Author:	Paul Youane [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
Jeff the God of Biscuits wrote:But if you look at the players missing for Wigan: 2 half backs [One being possibly the best player in the country], our [Arguably] best Prop. The Man of FN Steel. If you had say Briers & Monaghan, Morley & King out [What I would consider the corresponding players], would you still be confident of beating that Wigan 17? I think I know where my money would be. but that wasn't what was said was it? For your information the six missing for Warrington include 4 GB/England internationals, 1 New Zealand international and the club's leading try scorer last season. Taking Briers and Monaghan out would still give Bridge and Myler at halves with Clarke at hooker, Carvell in for Morley and Atkins in for King. Nobody could seriously state that team would be "struggling big time" against the Wigan 17 named above.

Author:	Paul Youane [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
LewCharnock wrote:Take them out and yes, you would be "struggling big time". Here you go then: Riley Evans Bridge Grix J. Monaghan Myler Monaghan Carvell Clarke Wood Anderson Westwood Harrison Higham Cooper McCarthy Solomona I do not think that team would be "struggling big time" either.

Author:	LewCharnock [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:29 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
Paul Youane wrote:Here you go then: Riley Evans Bridge Grix J. Monaghan Myler Monaghan Carvell Clarke Wood Anderson Westwood Harrison Higham Cooper McCarthy Solomona I do not think that team would be "struggling big time" either. Depends what you define as struggling. For me a club as big as Wire now would be struggling anything in getting beaten by all the top 6/7 clubs. I do think that side would get beaten by Wigan(even with those key players out), Saints, Leeds, Hudds, Hull FC, Hull KR.

Author:	NickyKiss [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:43 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
The injury to Hansen is a shame as his game has come on leaps and bounds and I thought he looked sharp at Salford but as people have said the area is that strong it's not a huge issue. It will open up more opportunites for Farrell, Mossop and Tuson and thats no bad thing.

Author:	twosevenzero [ Sat Jan 22, 2011 2:47 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Harrison hansen
Grimmy wrote::SLEEPY: There really should be some kind of ban on this, it's such a boring cop out. It goes without saying that we all think Mike Maguire has done a brilliant job so far, and I think this will turn out to be a smart move, but it would be a pretty boring forum if we didn't form our own opinions. Why is it a cop out ?, I trust his judgement on this decision, he see's Pryce and Marsh not just on match days, but on a regular basis, my opinion is that it is the correct move, that ok by you ?

Page 3 of 4	All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/