i remember comments being made to that tune.
i think you will find they haave. it was all about his head not being on the game because of his personal problems . it was definately on this board last march/april around the time when fieldn was dropped to the bench against warrington. you have short memories . it was definately on this board.

i think converted warrior has touched a nerve. do you really not remember the threads devoted to stuart fielden on here? Fickle some fans arnt they jonh , and not happy unless bad mouthing people.

No you are wrong, there were no nasty vindictive posts on the matter made on here, it was of course mentioned but certainly was not made in any nasty or vindictive way.

I think it is you and converted warrior that have the short memory in this case.

Yes i do, but non were nasty or vindicive when aimed at his personal situation.

Not sure what the last scentence is meant to mean, all fans of all sports are/can be fickle, are you suggesting i am fickle?

Could this be Charlie Seeling re-incarnated?

I miss Charlie Come back

Coley isn trying his hardest for Wigan, end of. Until we see some improvement in his desire to win the collision and want to take every ball in and smash them in every tackle he is going to get slated.
O'Carroll is recieving lots of praise and you know why? He is giving 100 per cent every game, the same could be said for Richards, Carmont, Leuluai, Hock, Hansen, Tomkins, McIllorum and young Sam and Ainscough. (If Ive missed any I apologise).

But the likes of Coley, Smith and Mathers just plod on earning their wage, they aint playing with pride or passion, we are 'Wigan Rugby League Club' its an honour to wear that shirt and play for the club, a lot of people would give their right arm to play for 'Wigan Rugby League Club' including me and I would play better than the lot of these cardboard cutout players.