It depends on the camera angle in relation to the players and the try line.

For me it is a legal pass. I may concede that it is the 'Leeds Rhinos flat pass'...but no further!

It also depends on the players position, which direction he's facing. From the photo you can't tell that with any degree of certainty so you can't make any conclusions.

Look at the eyes, if lunt was about to catch the ball he would be looking at it.

Unless hes got a squint

Perhaps that could explain why he knocked on, thats what you get when you dont pay attention

They were both running backwards and it was a perfectly legal pass!!!!!

It was taken from around the 20m and the players were on the 30m. Andy Raleigh playing the ball with Gilmour running onto a Lunt pass.

Any news on his injury?

Not broken as first suspected. Ligament damage most likely and depending on swelling he will be able to play on Sunday.

Just a quick one wadders old boy, i before except after c, not being pedantic just dont want anybody giving you grief over it

This was an email I sent to my MD over the same subject: