Saddened! wrote:Don't start the voluntary tackle stuff off again.

That wasn't even the most controversial one in Saints v Bradford games either. The knock on by Withers was. He still claims he didn't touch it. The video ref decision seemed to take about 9 days.

sir adrian morley wrote:Billy Thompson vhull at wilderspool in challenge cup.. disallowed 6 wire trys in what was simply biased reffing at its ultimate best

wire2004 wrote:I'd like to have a lil bit of a laugh.
So in the same vain of the worst plays you've ever seen.
I'd like to ask.
Excluding the obvious Russell smith call. What are the worst referee calls that you've ever seen in rugby?

Mine was a warrington vs widnes match in 2005 when were at tha Halton stadium. The referee. Who I forget who it was. Completely missed a successful drop goal from Lee Briers. Completely turning the game and I think we ended up losing as a result.

karetaker wrote:In the video ref era Ganson giving the try in the Hull Derby at magic weekend when the player was well off side. The RFL later apologised

WalterWizard wrote:was that not Bradford v Leeds mate at The Millennium stadium?