Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2012 6:15 pm
Knuckles
International Star
Joined: Jan 06 2012 Posts: 582 Location: London (formerly Saville Row)
fartown since 1961 wrote:Lee Briers the most blatant knock on I've ever seen the referee/touch judges decision play on !!!!! After the disallowed try for Leeds for a 'knock on' where does our sport get its credibility back.
This decision totally changed the games momentum today I'm ashamed to be a rugby league supporter !!!!
Silverwood has killed Leeds who runs the game the referee or Warrington, looks to me like Warrington what a totally sad day....
Time Cummins was sacked and refereeing standards changed dramatically !!!
Go and watch soccer, they deserve blokes like you !
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2012 7:05 pm
The_Wolfman
Club Owner
Joined: Aug 11 2003 Posts: 1494 Location: Warrington after many years of wandering
For me the pivotal moment was Sinfield going for the 2nd penalty. I knew from that moment that Leeds didn't have the confidence to go and win it. Leeds needed to get out to a big start like they did against Wigan in the semi to have a chance of winning.
As for the refs, I've learned that they actually do a great job. They go out to be the best they can and sometimes make mistakes. However, having come home and watched a match on the telly and seen how often, me and the crowd have got it completely wrong I never call a ref.
Maybe we should have a thread next week criticising every mistake made by a team on sky??
I mean she even cooks me pancakes
And Alka Seltzer when my tummy aches
If that ain't love then I don't know what love is
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2012 7:16 pm
Loyal Leeds Fan
Player Coach
Joined: Aug 05 2008 Posts: 1133
Chris Dalton wrote:No I didn't. I also praised the refereeing standard, and called Leeds gutless. Both of which I stand by.
One single relatively short post on the matter by a neutral and you call me obsessed. Your knee jerked. You assumed that I was a bitter rival fan or that I had some long standing irrational problem against Bailey. Obsessed. Ridiculous.
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Sun Aug 26, 2012 10:58 pm
Goochie
Player Coach
Joined: Jun 14 2009 Posts: 1620
The_Wolfman wrote:For me the pivotal moment was Sinfield going for the 2nd penalty. I knew from that moment that Leeds didn't have the confidence to go and win it. Leeds needed to get out to a big start like they did against Wigan in the semi to have a chance of winning.
As for the refs, I've learned that they actually do a great job. They go out to be the best they can and sometimes make mistakes. However, having come home and watched a match on the telly and seen how often, me and the crowd have got it completely wrong I never call a ref.
Maybe we should have a thread next week criticising every mistake made by a team on sky??
It's different when your teams involved though, at the game sometimes you see a blatant knock on from the stand that when you rewatch is actually a ball steal that the officials have got spot on, but an identical one next time you go is still wrong.
But when neutrals are coming on here claiming this is the end of rugby league with two refereeing decisions that are correct then that is more damaging than anything else could be.
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2012 7:52 am
Mild mannered Janitor
Club Owner
Joined: Feb 09 2004 Posts: 7735 Location: Here there and everywhere
Ferocious Aardvark wrote:Excellent and indisputable confirmation.
Sadly, though, the FACT that it did not go forward is of no interest to the sort of people on here, who probably don't believe Neil Armstrong ever set foot on the Moon, either. You're wasting your time. They WANT to feel the hard-done-by pain.
The briers "knock on" incident raises a question about those technical offences. I was under the impression that changing the direction of the flight of the ball in anything other than it's current direction or backwards from that direction was a knock on.
Now, if the incident which is being over analysed to the nth degree was not a knock on, then why do referees penalise the tackled ball carrier when they lose control of the ball and recover it whilst facing their own goal line.
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2012 8:06 am
Dally
International Chairman
Joined: Dec 22 2001 Posts: 14845
Mild mannered Janitor wrote:The briers "knock on" incident raises a question about those technical offences. I was under the impression that changing the direction of the flight of the ball in anything other than it's current direction or backwards from that direction was a knock on.
The current laws of the game say a knock on is when the ball is knocked towards the opponents deadball line.
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2012 8:13 am
Dally
International Chairman
Joined: Dec 22 2001 Posts: 14845
I was at the match and have not seen it on TV. Can someone please explain for me what happened after the Leeds disallowed try? The video ref's decision was no try, scrum defence. But, as I recall Leeds won the scrum. Was that "against the head"? Did I miss the actual scrum and rejoin after another in the same position because I was trying to work out the decision? Did the ref give it the wrong way round? Or, did Warrington actually win it and I suffered from some sort of illusion?
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2012 8:25 am
Milly
International Board Member
Joined: Dec 28 2002 Posts: 3555 Location: Warrington
Dally wrote:I was at the match and have not seen it on TV. Can someone please explain for me what happened after the Leeds disallowed try? The video ref's decision was no try, scrum defence. But, as I recall Leeds won the scrum. Was that "against the head"? Did I miss the actual scrum and rejoin after another in the same position because I was trying to work out the decision? Did the ref give it the wrong way round? Or, did Warrington actually win it and I suffered from some sort of illusion?
Leeds got the scrum because they were the defending side at the time! Hodgson was carrying the ball in so Wire were the attacking side. He lost the ball in the tackle (first knock on) and Leuluai then flicked it away (second knock on) which Delaney picked up from an off side position. It wasn't a try becaue Delaney was off side and Leeds got the feed because Wire knocked on first.
Post subject: Re: Rugby League no credibility left anymore !!!!
Posted: Mon Aug 27, 2012 8:29 am
cravenpark1
Player Coach
Joined: Dec 17 2009 Posts: 2862 Location: live in gosport wos hull
Dally wrote:I was at the match and have not seen it on TV. Can someone please explain for me what happened after the Leeds disallowed try? The video ref's decision was no try, scrum defence. But, as I recall Leeds won the scrum. Was that "against the head"? Did I miss the actual scrum and rejoin after another in the same position because I was trying to work out the decision? Did the ref give it the wrong way round? Or, did Warrington actually win it and I suffered from some sort of illusion?
the way i so it and i was their if the try was not a try why was the ball given to Leeds and not to warrie it still does not make sense to me i will have to think about, it but saying that warrie would still have won
JOHN THE REDBOY I have been a rovers fan all my life and my grandkids are as well
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 46 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum