A tough call for me. The football lines don’t help. You can see why refs have such a tough job.

Either way these things seem to even out over the season so no doubt we will be raging at a perfectly good try of ours chaulked off soon enough.

Good to hear the young lad is ok.

Yeah looks a try for me. Having said that they were lucky not to have another yellow for the tackle on Scurr. Think if they hadn't have had a man already in the bin, they'd have seen yellow for that.

What about Mitch Clark coming back possibly? He was a fans favourite and we could do with another prop at the moment.

Played for Newcastle last night (as did MoM Hallas) so I doubt this is happening.

Newcastle have spent big money on their squad so unless they're now skint or players are unsettled being up there I can't see them letting any leave. Clark was decent for this level but he never seemed to realise his potential.

Mick said scrapping around the championship last few years, my guess is welham or walshaw

Dirty Walshaw isn't good enough. Welham would be alright. What's the extent of the injuries to the two oil tankers? If they're out medium to long term then another prop will be needed.

Only others I can think of is Kirk or olbison

I thought Olbison had retired?

Tom drives a tank engine I believe