Assuming these lists are correct:
Harry Sunderland Award
Lance Todd Trophy
It's quite a lot.
Probably easier to list the exceptions:
Harry Sunderland:
1999 - Henry Paul (Bradford)
2000 - Chris Joynt (St Helens)
2001 - Michael Withers (Bradford)
2002 - Paul Deacon (Bradford) - Debatable but he did debut for Oldham in SL.
Lance Todd:
1997 - Tommy Martyn (St Helens)
2000 - Henry Paul (Bradford)
2001 - Sean Long (St Helens)
2003 - Garry Connolly (Leeds)
2004 - Sean Long (St Helens)
2006 - Sean Long (St Helens)
2007 - Leon Pryce (St Helens)
Or something like that.