The poster was right Big Mick isn't aggressive enough but had a safe game Walters offers more at the moment especially with his offloads.

Whilst Mikokaj hasn’t had the best season this year he’s still only 24 and you are delusional if you think Walters is as good as him or Holroyd or ever will be.

Difficult to say who will turn out to be the better prop of the 3.
But this season Walters wins that argument hands down.

I think they all offer three very different things as props, and it’s a shame we’re not keeping them together.

Holroyd was not mentioned you are the one who is delusional.
Are other posters not allowed to post their opinions that differ to yours.
Big mick does not have any mongrel in him unlike holroyd and he can’t ball handle.He has size and pace and does not use it .
Why did Shaun Wayne not use him and that man knows a good forward.

Big micks only 24 how old is walters?

and yet Mik won player of the year twice in a row - basically carried the pack on his shoulders for stretches
what does Wane know exactly, look at his embarrasing picks in the world cup last season - lucky to still be in the job

Mik had a shoulder injury he carried for part of that season ( along with our entire pack). He should have done a saints and got it fixed but clearly wanted to play for England.

Mik hasn't been great this year but he's also not had to carry us.

Hopefully next year he gets back to his best

Holroyd has everything to be a star, his return from missing most of last year has been pretty great.

Walters always wanted and needed more game time. Getting dropped after good performances wasn't taken well and I can't blame him for looking elsewhere.

He has stuff to work on but like the other two ro but age and desire is clearly on his side

Walters will get more international call ups than Oledski as will Holroyd unfortunately big mick has the frame and athletic ability to be the best but just too nice to cut it.