Post subject: Re: Have Leeds lost hunger, as a club?
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2023 5:49 am
Zoo Zoo Boom
First Team Player
Joined: Dec 11 2020 Posts: 1104
MjM wrote:They sacked McDermott nine months after he won his last Grand Final. I know lots of people were calling do his head at various times before then but the reality is very few clubs would have done it - indeed the media commentary when it actually happened was about how shocking it was.
McDermott should have gone at the end of the 2015 season. He thought it was great idea for the club to have a few seasons in the doldrums so the supporters would appreciate the good times even more. McDermott started this and the club have been unable to turn it around.
They are now in a catch 22 - they can't get the better players because the club is a shambles and the can't redress the shambles util they get better players.
Two of the big signings of the summer can't get in the side of their current club - what does that say?
Post subject: Re: Have Leeds lost hunger, as a club?
Posted: Sun Sep 17, 2023 6:16 am
MjM
International Chairman
Joined: Dec 22 2001 Posts: 6879 Location: The Motorway City of the 1970s
Zoo Zoo Boom wrote:McDermott should have gone at the end of the 2015 season. He thought it was great idea for the club to have a few seasons in the doldrums so the supporters would appreciate the good times even more.
We can't live our lives in hindsight. McDermott was never going to be sacked after 2015 and he'd credit in the bank for all of 2016. Maybe after Cas away in '17 there was a chance but end of that season meant the reality was he was safe again. And rightly so because we won the title again!
Let all the doubters keep doubting and those who believe keep believing.
We’re only interested in those in the bubble. Anyone who wants to come in the bubble, you can come in.
Joined: Dec 29 2005 Posts: 2248 Location: with the barefoot girls
Zoo Zoo Boom wrote:Rohan Smith's defence is there are lots of young inexperienced kids in the team - let's look at last night's team.
1. Hooley - inexperienced at this level but 25 years old with >100 games in a good Champ side 2. Fusitua - first choice 3. Newman - first choice - might behave like a petulant child - hear he offered a fan out last night!! 4. Handley - first choice 5. Olpharts - experienced SL player 6. Martin - international player and first choice albeit not in this position 7. Sinfield - agreed 8. Oldeski - first choice 9. O'Connor - first choice 10 Holroyd - first choice 11 McDonnell - first choice 12.Gannon - agreed 13.Smith - first coice 14.Lisone - first choice - ex NRL player 15.Johnson - agreed 16. Ruan - agreed 17. Donaldson - experienced SL player
It is a fallacy about young players - there were 11 players who would play if everyone was fit. There were 4 young/academy players - Johnson it could be argued either way. This was not a side filled with academy players. There is no way this side should be conceding 60 points - looking in from the outside they were sending a message to the coach - time to go.
Time for Newman to go too - he needs a more structured stricter environment where he can grow up.
Apart from the letting Newman go bit I agree. It's too easy to keep trotting out the " young / inexperienced " line up excuse. It's the senior players under performing week after week and the lack of organisation and leadership that has been our biggest problem all season. Smith has failed to sort that out all year.
Woody: Can I pour you a draft, Mr. Peterson?
Norm: A little early, isn't it Woody?
Woody: For a beer?
Norm: No, for stupid questions.
All the warning signs are there that the problems we have are not going anywhere with RS in charge. So much of the season people have given reasons and patience for where the teams been at, this is now as low a point as we've had in recent years, not much better than 96 and gives bullsgate a run for its money. Talk about missing players all you like and give more excuses but he cant get anything like the best out of some pretty experienced players and his playing philosophy has been a mess all year. 10 games into next year and we're going to be in even more trouble.
Who do we get you ask, well, it's a pretty low bar that's been set. Not a good time for the smith family.
Are you suggesting we can't have a good team for 40 years?? According to GH we've always spent to the cap. Given how bad the side has been for almost 10 years that speaks volumes about how appallingly managed our spend has been.
I said the same about the kids line. The players we had out could have competed much better against Wigan and Cats. With no halfbacks everybody else has to put in a real shift as a team, and they just haven't.
Joined: May 28 2002 Posts: 7450 Location: Isca Dumnoniorum
Look at that spine though - a champonship fullback, an 18 year old, a centre, and a hooker in his first full season in SL... There are reasons why this is the case, but realistically this is why we have been pointless for two weeks against top 4 opposition.
Confidence is obviously shot too. There is no belief, and not much to play for when we get behind on the scoreboard.
The Cas game is another matter and Smith has stated he expects (or at least wants) a win to bring a close to this awful season.
Exeter Rhino wrote:Look at that spine though - a champonship fullback, an 18 year old, a centre, and a hooker in his first full season in SL... There are reasons why this is the case, but realistically this is why we have been pointless for two weeks against top 4 opposition.
Confidence is obviously shot too. There is no belief, and not much to play for when we get behind on the scoreboard.
The Cas game is another matter and Smith has stated he expects (or at least wants) a win to bring a close to this awful season.
Thats all well and good but how are you going to explain the real problems with these performances? Falling off tackles, lack of any intent carrying the ball, lack of desire, unforced errors, dumb penalties and 6 agains, you know, the basic skills and mindset that go before any win. If turning up for yourself and eachother and the players at the side of you isn't enough to play for then theres some more weeding out of players that don't want it to come.
Wow , our ambition has no ends , a win against a dire Cas team is the height of our achievement hopes . Lets hope Cas are not up for it or the pre season clash against Hunslet may be our next win target
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
