Ferocious Aardvark wrote:No it isn't! For a start, the question suggested: "Can I see that bag" is not a rhetorical question; even if it was, or could be, the post provided the answer to the question, whereas the whole point of a rhetorical question is it implies its own answer. So it fails on every count It's about as far away from being a rhetorical question as Eric Pickles is from svelte!
Not that question.
The question that asks "Why couldn't it be ...." is the rhetorical one because it seems obvious to me that answer to "Can I see that bag" could just as easily have been "Certainly".
Happy to clear that up.