Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:25 am
wire-quin
Player Coach
Joined: Jan 23 2006 Posts: 7392 Location: Looking for a coach that can coach
King Street Cat wrote:I've got to ask what these new blue, Northern, Labour supporters saw in millionaire, old Etonian, bon vivant, Boris Johnson, or millionaire, old Etonian, investment manager, Jacob Rees-Mogg. You can paint Starmer as an establishment figure all you want, but Johnson and JRM are the establishment's establishment!
The difference being they don't hide it. What a joke the labour leadership campaign was listening to each and every one of the telling us how they were brought up in council house and attended state schools.
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:37 am
wrencat1873
Club Coach
Joined: Apr 24 2011 Posts: 17980
wire-quin wrote:The difference being they don't hide it. What a joke the labour leadership campaign was listening to each and every one of the telling us how they were brought up in council house and attended state schools.
They may not hide their upbringing but, FFS, Boris is self proclaimed "man of the people" Never has been and never will be
Lets be honest here, its impossible for anyone from an "estate", with a regional accent to become Prime Minister, those that may begin their political life with a regional accent soon dispense with it as they climb the political ladder, as do most (not all) successful business leaders.
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 12:28 pm
sally cinnamon
Club Coach
Joined: Oct 12 2004 Posts: 16271
Backwoodsman wrote:Unless I have missed it I can’t see Yvette Cooper assigned any senior position. Surprising as she is an experienced and capable politician.
It's because she got the job of Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee which is one of the most high profile. Similarly Hilary Benn got the Chair of Exiting the EU Select Committee.
Only backbenchers are allowed to chair a Select Committee, if you're in the Shadow Cabinet you have to resign the post.
A Select Committee chair has more real power to hold the government to account through Parliament, cross-examining Ministers and civil servants, requesting the publication of documents, than a Shadow spokesperson which is more about being a spokesperson in the media. So it was unlikely that Cooper or Benn would relinquish those roles. Also Select Committee chairs get about £15k pay increment on their MP salary, I don't think there's a pay award attached to being in the Shadow Cabinet so that would involve a pay cut too!
If Labour were to win the next election I would expect Cooper and Benn to go in the actual Cabinet.
Backwoodsman wrote:Unless I have missed it I can’t see Yvette Cooper assigned any senior position. Surprising as she is an experienced and capable politician.
It's because she got the job of Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee which is one of the most high profile. Similarly Hilary Benn got the Chair of Exiting the EU Select Committee.
Only backbenchers are allowed to chair a Select Committee, if you're in the Shadow Cabinet you have to resign the post.
A Select Committee chair has more real power to hold the government to account through Parliament, cross-examining Ministers and civil servants, requesting the publication of documents, than a Shadow spokesperson which is more about being a spokesperson in the media. So it was unlikely that Cooper or Benn would relinquish those roles. Also Select Committee chairs get about £15k pay increment on their MP salary, I don't think there's a pay award attached to being in the Shadow Cabinet so that would involve a pay cut too!
If Labour were to win the next election I would expect Cooper and Benn to go in the actual Cabinet.
Challenge Cup winners 2009 2010 2012 2019 League Leaders 2011 2016
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 12:46 pm
wire-quin
Player Coach
Joined: Jan 23 2006 Posts: 7392 Location: Looking for a coach that can coach
wrencat1873 wrote:They may not hide their upbringing but, FFS, Boris is self proclaimed "man of the people" Never has been and never will be
Lets be honest here, its impossible for anyone from an "estate", with a regional accent to become Prime Minister, those that may begin their political life with a regional accent soon dispense with it as they climb the political ladder, as do most (not all) successful business leaders.
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 12:55 pm
bren2k
Club Coach
Joined: Mar 24 2010 Posts: 15521 Location: Ossett
Ornery Optimist wrote:He did seem extremely silent during the Labour anti-Semitism arguments,despite the fact that his wife and 2 children are of the Jewish faith.
Perhaps because he knew it was all bo11ocks?
The sum total of 0.08% of the Labour membership resigned, were expelled or received formal warnings in relation to anti-Semitism, and the Home Affairs Select Committee concluded that there was "no reliable, empirical evidence to support the notion that there is a higher prevalence of antisemitic attitudes within the Labour Party than any other political party." There remains no evidence whatsoever that Corbyn himself has ever said or done anything even vaguely anti-Semitic.
The real issue of course is support for Palestinians and/or criticism of Israel, which a large and well-funded lobby have successfully transmogrified into antisemitism; ironically, conflating Israel to mean 'all Jews' is in itself a breach of the IHRA definitions, but that document seems to be useful only as a convenient stick with which to beat anti-Zionists.
The biggest con trick of a generation, whereby tens of thousands of perfectly decent people were labelled as anti-semites, in a concerted effort to destroy one man.
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 1:20 pm
Backwoodsman
International Star
Joined: Aug 09 2011 Posts: 1906 Location: Deepest North Yorkshire Woodland
sally cinnamon wrote:It's because she got the job of Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee which is one of the most high profile. Similarly Hilary Benn got the Chair of Exiting the EU Select Committee.
Only backbenchers are allowed to chair a Select Committee, if you're in the Shadow Cabinet you have to resign the post.
A Select Committee chair has more real power to hold the government to account through Parliament, cross-examining Ministers and civil servants, requesting the publication of documents, than a Shadow spokesperson which is more about being a spokesperson in the media. So it was unlikely that Cooper or Benn would relinquish those roles. Also Select Committee chairs get about £15k pay increment on their MP salary, I don't think there's a pay award attached to being in the Shadow Cabinet so that would involve a pay cut too!
If Labour were to win the next election I would expect Cooper and Benn to go in the actual Cabinet.
Thanks, wasn’t aware of that.
sally cinnamon wrote:It's because she got the job of Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee which is one of the most high profile. Similarly Hilary Benn got the Chair of Exiting the EU Select Committee.
Only backbenchers are allowed to chair a Select Committee, if you're in the Shadow Cabinet you have to resign the post.
A Select Committee chair has more real power to hold the government to account through Parliament, cross-examining Ministers and civil servants, requesting the publication of documents, than a Shadow spokesperson which is more about being a spokesperson in the media. So it was unlikely that Cooper or Benn would relinquish those roles. Also Select Committee chairs get about £15k pay increment on their MP salary, I don't think there's a pay award attached to being in the Shadow Cabinet so that would involve a pay cut too!
If Labour were to win the next election I would expect Cooper and Benn to go in the actual Cabinet.
Post subject: Re: Millionaire N London Barrister leads Labour
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 2:52 pm
wotsupcas
International Star
Joined: Mar 02 2014 Posts: 915
Backwoodsman wrote:Unless I have missed it I can’t see Yvette Cooper assigned any senior position. Surprising as she is an experienced and capable politician.
It would be interesting to see Momentum as a stand alone party & see what relevance they still have to the working class. It was also give Labour a chance to be a serious ,moderate alternative to Conservative.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 134 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum